Electronic signature vs. digital signature: what’s the difference?
An electronic signature is a broad way of signing a document electronically. A digital signature is a specific technology that uses cryptography to help verify the origin and integrity of electronic information.
Electronic signatures and digital signatures sound like two names for the same thing.
In everyday conversation, people often use them that way. But technically, they aren’t identical.
Both can play a role in signing documents without paper, but they solve somewhat different problems. Here’s how they work and how to decide what you need.
1.What is an electronic signature?
An electronic signature, often called an e-signature, is an electronic action or representation that a person adopts with the intention of signing a document.
Under the U.S. ESIGN Act, electronic signatures can take several forms. For example:
- Typing your name into a signature field
- Drawing your signature with a mouse or finger
- Clicking a button to indicate agreement
- Using an electronic-signature service to complete a signing process
- Applying another electronic symbol or process intended as a signature
The signature doesn’t necessarily need to resemble handwriting. What matters is the person’s intent to sign and the connection between that action and the relevant document.
For example, a client might open a services agreement, review its terms, type their name, and select a button to complete the signing process. That can constitute an electronic signature, depending on the circumstances.
2.What is a digital signature?
A digital signature is a particular type of cryptographic mechanism.
It uses mathematical techniques to help establish that information was signed using a particular cryptographic key and that the signed information hasn’t been altered afterward.
Digital signatures commonly rely on public-key cryptography. This involves two related keys:
Used to create the digital signature.
Used to verify that signature.
When someone digitally signs information, software uses the private key to produce a cryptographic signature associated with the data. Another system can then use the corresponding public key to verify it.
If the signed data changes, signature verification ordinarily fails. A digital signature can therefore provide strong evidence of document integrity.
However, proving which cryptographic key created a signature isn’t necessarily the same as proving the real-world identity of the person using that key. That depends on how the key was issued, controlled, and associated with an identity.
3.Electronic signature vs. digital signature: side by side
| Topic | Electronic signature | Digital signature |
|---|---|---|
| Basic meaning | Electronic action or symbol adopted to sign | Cryptographic mechanism for signing data |
| Main purpose | Express intent or agreement | Provide cryptographic verification of origin and integrity |
| Example | Typing a name and clicking Sign | Signing a PDF using a certificate-based digital ID |
| Cryptography required | Not inherently | Yes |
| Digital certificate required | No | Not for every digital signature, though certificate-based signing commonly uses one |
| Evidence of intent | Depends on the signing process | Still depends on the surrounding process |
| Detecting changes | Depends on the system and controls | Cryptographic verification can detect changes to signed data |
| Legal effect | Depends on applicable law and circumstances | Depends on applicable law and circumstances |
The important distinction is that electronic signatures describe a broad category of signing actions, while digital signatures describe a specific cryptographic technique.
A digital signature can be used as part of an electronic-signature process, but not every electronic signature uses a digital signature.
4.How does a digital certificate fit in?
Digital certificates are often associated with digital signatures, but the terms shouldn’t be confused.
A digital certificate is an electronic credential that associates a public key with information about a person, organization, or other entity. Certificates may be issued by certificate authorities or other trusted providers.
When a document uses certificate-based digital signing, the certificate can help a verifier determine which public key belongs to the claimed signer. This allows the recipient to check the cryptographic signature and evaluate the associated certificate.
The level of assurance depends on factors such as:
- How the certificate was issued
- Whether the claimed identity was verified
- How the private key is protected
- Whether the certificate is trusted and valid
- Whether the signed document has been changed
A digital certificate provides part of the technical trust framework. It doesn’t eliminate every possible identity or fraud risk.
5.Is a signing certificate the same as a digital signature?
No. This is an important distinction.
Electronic-signature platforms often provide a signing certificate, sometimes called a certificate of completion or signing record. It might contain:
- The signer’s name and email address
- When the signing invitation was sent
- When the document was opened
- When the signature was completed
- Authentication or verification steps performed
- Other recorded signing events
This information can help demonstrate how the signing process occurred.
But that type of certificate is not necessarily a cryptographic digital certificate, and it doesn’t automatically establish that the PDF contains a certificate-based digital signature.
A signing platform may use both an event-based signing record and cryptographic document protections. They serve different purposes and should be described accurately.
6.Are electronic signatures less secure than digital signatures?
Not necessarily in every practical situation.
Digital signatures provide particular cryptographic protections, especially for detecting changes to signed information. But the overall security of a signing process depends on much more than the type of signature.
For example, consider two situations.
A person uses a certificate-based digital signature, but their private key has been compromised.
A person signs through a controlled electronic workflow that records consent, requires additional authentication, preserves the completed record, and restricts access.
The technical digital signature in Situation A provides cryptographic functionality, but the compromised key undermines confidence in who used it.
The electronic-signature workflow in Situation B may provide useful evidence of consent and attribution, even if it doesn’t involve an individual certificate-based digital signature.
Neither example establishes automatic legal validity or superiority. The appropriate choice depends on the transaction, risks, and applicable requirements.
7.Are both types of signatures legally binding?
Potentially, yes. In the United States, the federal ESIGN Act and applicable state laws generally recognize qualifying electronic signatures. The law does not generally require every electronic signature to use certificate-based digital-signature technology.
Instead, relevant considerations include the signer’s intent, consent, attribution, the nature of the transaction, and applicable recordkeeping requirements.
Some documents and transactions require additional formalities or are subject to statutory exceptions.
Digital signatures may be specifically required or preferred in certain regulated, governmental, or international workflows.
A cryptographic digital signature alone doesn’t guarantee that the underlying agreement is legally enforceable.
For more detail, see our guide: Are electronic signatures legally binding? ESIGN and UETA explained.
8.When should you use an electronic signature?
An ordinary electronic-signature workflow may be appropriate for many common business documents. Examples include:
- Service agreements
- Consulting contracts
- Nondisclosure agreements
- Engagement letters
- Routine authorizations
- Other business documents suitable for electronic signing
A dedicated signing platform can make these processes easier by coordinating signers, recording relevant events, and keeping completed documents organized.
The important question is whether the process provides suitable evidence and safeguards for the particular agreement.
9.When might you need a digital signature?
A certificate-based digital signature may be appropriate when you need stronger cryptographic document-integrity controls or must satisfy specific technical requirements. For example:
- Government or regulated submissions. Some systems require particular certificate-based signatures.
- Technical documents. Organizations may require cryptographic verification to detect document modifications.
- Cross-border transactions. Certain jurisdictions or transactions may require particular types of electronic signatures or trusted certificates.
- Internal security policies. A business may require certificate-based signing for specified documents.
Before choosing a solution, confirm the actual technical and legal requirements.
Not all electronic-signature services provide individual certificate-based digital signatures, and not all certificates are accepted for every purpose.
10.How Sign. with Confidence fits in
Sign. with Confidence is designed to make everyday electronic signing straightforward. You upload a document, assign signers, and send a signing request.
Recipients can sign through a private browser link without creating an account or installing an application.
Sign. tracks progress, sends reminders, and provides a completed document with a certificate recording details of the signing process. An optional email verification code can add another step before signing.
The certificate also records a SHA-256 fingerprint of the original file: a code that changes if the file’s contents change. Sign. keeps the fingerprint of every sealed copy too, so anyone holding the signed PDF can check that it hasn’t changed since it was sealed.
Sign. doesn’t currently apply a certificate-based digital signature to completed documents. Its certificate is a record of the signing process, not a cryptographic digital certificate, and the check relies on Sign.’s own records rather than verification other software can do independently.
For many ordinary business workflows, these features help make electronic signatures easier to collect and document.
If your transaction requires a particular cryptographic signature standard or trusted digital certificate, verify that the chosen signing service specifically supports it.
See how everyday electronic signing feels.
Try the signing experienceJust a demo. Nothing is saved or sent.
11.How to decide which type you need
Start with the document and the requirements of the transaction. Ask yourself:
- What am I signing? Is it an ordinary business agreement, a regulated submission, or a document with special legal formalities?
- Do I need a record of consent and signing events? A signing platform’s audit records may be particularly useful for business agreements.
- Do I need cryptographic proof that the document hasn’t changed? If so, evaluate the available digital-signature and document-integrity protections.
- Is a particular certificate required? Some workflows specify accepted certificate authorities, digital IDs, or cryptographic standards.
- How sensitive is the transaction? Consider the appropriate level of signer authentication, access control, and record retention.
You may find that a straightforward electronic-signature platform is sufficient. Or you may need a more specialized digital-signature solution.
The bottom line
Electronic signatures and digital signatures are related, but they’re not interchangeable.
An electronic signature is a broad way of expressing agreement or signing electronically. A digital signature uses cryptography to help verify the origin and integrity of signed information.
For many everyday business agreements, a well-designed electronic-signature process may be appropriate without requiring each signer to obtain a digital certificate. For transactions with specific technical, regulatory, or legal requirements, certificate-based digital signatures may be necessary.
Choose based on the document and its requirements. Not on which term sounds more secure.
Frequently asked questions
Is a digital signature the same as an electronic signature?
No. Electronic signature is a broad legal and functional concept. A digital signature is a specific cryptographic mechanism that can be used as part of an electronic-signature process.
Is a typed signature an electronic signature?
It can be. If someone types their name with the intent to sign a record, that action may qualify as an electronic signature under applicable law.
Do electronic signatures require digital certificates?
Not generally. Many electronic signatures use typed or drawn signatures, signing actions, and recorded evidence without requiring each signer to possess a certificate-based digital ID.
Are digital signatures more secure?
Digital signatures provide cryptographic verification of signed data, which can offer strong integrity protections. Overall security also depends on identity verification, key protection, system design, and the surrounding signing process.
Can a digital signature be legally binding?
Yes, depending on the transaction and applicable law. Digital-signature technology doesn’t automatically make every agreement enforceable.
Is a signing certificate the same as a digital certificate?
No. A signing certificate may record events such as who signed and when. A cryptographic digital certificate associates a public key with identifying information and is used in certificate-based trust systems.
Does Sign. with Confidence use digital signatures?
Not certificate-based digital signatures. Sign. with Confidence provides electronic signing and a certificate of completion that records the signing process, including a SHA-256 fingerprint of the original file. If your transaction requires a certificate-based digital signature or a particular trusted digital ID, use a service that specifically supports it.
Which is better for signing business contracts?
For many ordinary business contracts, an electronic-signature process with appropriate consent, authentication, and records may be suitable. Certificate-based digital signatures may be preferable or required when stronger technical assurances or specific standards apply.
References
This article provides general information about electronic and digital signatures and is not legal or security advice. Requirements vary by jurisdiction, document, and transaction.